Since you didn't put parameters on whether they can be alive/dead or real/fantasy or Pixies/Non-Pixies

Here are my 5......

1) Skip
2) Ty Pennington (Extreme Home Makeover)
3) Johnny Smith (The Dead Zone Lead Character played by Anthony Michael Hall)
4) Steve Watson (Monster House)
5) Jesse James (Monster Garage)


As for who I would want to stay for breakfast.... you can figure that out on your own....