I've had the exact same problem. The first jelly toy I got irritated the hell outa me. I recently bought some new toys *grin* and the one smelled so strong I was really worried it would be a problem and irritate me again. But..to my delight. It didn't. I say give it a try. You never know. As for the smell. Mine has disapated somewhat. So I have hope that will continue.
Good luck!
~Eliza

__________________
"Only the united beat of sex and heart together can create ecstasy" ~Anaïs Nin


"The full moon is calling, the fever is high.
And the wicked wind whispers and moans.
You got your demons, you got desires
Well, I got a few of my own"
~The Eagles