John Stevens sang As Time Goes By from Casablanca, and Diana sang My Heart Will Go On from Titanic.

-grins- Flutelady, it doesn't show live there? I guess I figured that because it says live, it was showing at the same time everywhere. Huh, I learn something new every day ;)

Thanks Ready4Ty. :) I figured John would go for old. He has an amazing voice, but I think he's also very genre specific. That voice is just too smooth and sauve to fit most things.

Nope Gilly, it comes on at 8pm PST, 3 hrs later than on the east coast! Last year I accidently found out who won, long before it showed here. Talk about a bummer.... (especially since it wasn't Clay)

I am not a Fantasia fan, simply because of her attitude. But, she earned points with me tonight. She sang and behaved beautifully... WOW!

let's see I would pick Diane, JPL and John Stevens for tonight's bottom three...Jasmine had a rough night, George was not great...well let's say with the exception of LaToya and Fantasia the night was pretty lack luster....Say what you will about Fantasia's personality she was exceptional last night...better than a good many professionals...If I had to pick on the basis of last nights performances she wins Hands Down...but that attitude....ugggg

She's a diva. Lord save us.

As much as I like them all, I would guess JPL, Jasmine and Diana to be in the lower three, with JPL being the one to leave. Dammit, I really like JPL, and I enjoyed his performance but I would have to say he just may be the one to go.
Fantasia sang well, but "best performance ever on American Idol"????? I don' t think so! I think you've got it right, Gilly................she's a Diva alright, in the worst sense of the word.
Just my NSHO (not so humble opinion):D

-giggles- She'll give some of our "current" diva's a run sometime.

I like JPL. He's just sooo "boy next door". Very likeable, very friendly, and what not. I'm not sure he's pop star material, but I definatly like him.

John Stevens sang the song from casa blanca "you must remember this a kiss is just a kiss" and diana sand "my heart will go on" from titanic...I thought latoya and fantasia and JPL were awsome last night...actually the only two who weren't great were diana and cutie girl with the flower..why can't I remember her name...shoot...lol

JPL sucks!!

I am not so happy with the outcome tonight... but I won't give it away... :(

I'm not happy with it either, but I sort of figured it would turn out this way. I hate it sometimes when I'm right. :(

Yeah I definitely thought it would have turned out differently tonight but what can you do I guess.

It just ended here. I was sooo wanting to read this site earlier this evening, but was afraid that I'd find out who got the boot...

Even tho someone has to leave each week, I'm always sad to see them go. The look in their eyes always gives me a lump in my throat. The bottom 3 tonight was as it should be... and it's just a matter of who leaves when, they're all on their way home. Ever notice how much better they sing on result night?

who got booted? I was at "friends" night!

PM me if no one wants to give it away

Since it's been shown all across the contry by now, there's no harm in telling.




JPL got voted off tonight. I was really sorry to see him go. They all did really well last night, but I think he did the least good job.




Next week they'll be doing Barry Manilow music. John Stevens should do well.